Skip to content
Casual interior with table service
Home / Menu

Menu

Pizza Menu Waterville NY

New York Pizzeria keeps the pizza menu Waterville NY diners expect, with a spread that runs from starters to sweets. The menu is built around Appetizers, Salads, Desserts, and Lunch Specials, so a meal can start light or move into something more filling.

The kitchen also makes wraps, baked pasta, and cold subs. Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, Pizza Logs, and Antipasto suit a quick start. Baked Ziti and Chicken Riggies bring a fuller plate. A Tossed Salad or Kristen Salad fits a lighter order, while Any Large Cold Sub gives a straightforward sandwich option.

Dessert stays simple and familiar with Grinch Cake and Carrot Cake. The menu also includes catering, so the same kitchen can handle a larger order when the table needs more than a single meal. For a broader look at the shop itself, see the main Waterville pizzeria page.

Comfortable seating inside a pizzeria

Dishes

  • Fish Fry
    Fish Fry
  • Chicken Alfredo
    Chicken Alfredo
  • Sausage Pizza
    Sausage Pizza
  • Meat Pizza
    Meat Pizza
  • Plain Cheese Pizza
    Plain Cheese Pizza
  • Meat Lovers Pizza
    Meat Lovers Pizza
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
  • Antipasto Salad
    Antipasto Salad
  • Philly Cheese Steak Sub
    Philly Cheese Steak Sub
  • Cheese Fries
    Cheese Fries

    Small, large

    $5.00
  • Hawaiian Pizza
    Hawaiian Pizza
  • Calzone
    Calzone